Half SourforMarrow Hill

Seventy years on the shelf. From six feet, you look like the store brand.

Half SourforMarrow Hill Foods

Our answer to your account review. The brand problem, the strategy, three early ideas, the team and the first 90 days, all on aisle 7.

Your can is in the middle of this shelf. Tap the one you'd pick up.
The briefBay 1Prepared for the final round, November 2026

You told us shoppers trust you and don't pick you.

"Trusted by three generations. Chosen by fewer of them every year."

Your review brief, section 2.1

We walked 40 stores before we wrote a word. Your soup isn't losing on taste. The store label took your blue, your band and your layout, then charged 80 cents less. Everything you've spent on that can since 1956 now works for Ostler's Markets too.

14.8Your percent share of soup this year, down from 24.1 in 2019
22.3Store label share this year, up from 11.8 in 2019
$316MA year at the register, the 9.3 share points you've lost at about $34M each
The shelf testBay 2UPC 0 41688 01956 3

Put our ideas on your can. Then walk backward.

Three early territories, one crowded shelf. Swap the label, then drag your distance from one foot to twelve. A shopper decides from about six.

6 ftWhere a shopper decides
5 of 24your facings

Distances are our own read from the 40 store walks. The day 38 shelf test replaces them with 600 shoppers.

Through the storeBay 3Our pick, in words, comes below

A good idea survives the walk to the car.

Drag the can from the shelf to the recipe card. Each stop is redrawn for the territory you pick here.

We'd take The Long Hill and The Count into the shelf test, and hold Home Sick as a winter line for the hill to carry. The Long Hill gets better with every facing you win, and Daybasket can't borrow it without standing beside you and finishing your drawing.

Walk the aisleBay 4Scroll to walk

Seven years, one shelf.

24.1your share
11.8store label

Seven years, one shelf.

The planBay 5Eye-level, 24 facings, section 7-14

Three decisions we'd make in January.

Fix the can before the campaign.

You'll print about 180 million cans next year. That's the biggest medium you own, and it costs the same to say something on it. Label system first, then everything else follows it.

We'd stop the seasonal label wraps. They train buyers to expect a different can each quarter.

Sell it to the store buyer first.

Resets decide the shelf long before a shopper sees a film. Dee's team gets the story, the velocity plan and the shipper specs 16 weeks ahead of each reset.

We'd stop asking for facings on brand love. Buyers respond to dollars per linear foot.

One idea for three years.

Your last six campaigns each ran about 14 months. A shape only becomes yours by repeating it, so the can, the endcap, the phone and the shelter all run one drawing until 2029.

We'd stop briefing a new campaign line every fiscal year, ours included.

The first 90 days fit on one list.

We start January 4. Check things off as you read, because it's the order we'd do them in, and a few of these need your people.

The teamBay 612 items, 90 days

Everyone on your account, by weight.

You'll see the people you met in the room, listed in order of hours. Tap a name. Drop a line in the bill below and they come off this label.

For RenataBay 7Four signers, four questions

Renata, what do you have to give up?

Chief Marketing Officer

Less than you're expecting. Turn off anything on The Long Hill can and see what it costs you with loyal buyers and what it does to your distance from Daybasket.

Anders, what's a share point worth?

Chief Executive Officer

About $34M at the register, $22M to you after the retailer's margin, and $7.04M in gross margin. Drag the points you think we'll win back by 2029 and the shelf follows.

16.4Share by 2029, from 14.8 today
7Eye-level facings of 24, from 5
$11.3MGross margin a year at that share
0.79Points that pay for the year one bill

Dee, here's what the buyers will say.

VP Sales

Marcus, here's the fee build.

Procurement

Hours times rate, by line, with nothing hidden in a blended number. Decide how much of the retainer we keep at risk against the scorecard.

10 percent

Rates hold for the three-year term. Third-party costs pass through at cost with three bids over $50,000. No markup on production or media.

The scorecard behind the held-back fee

Share stops falling, four-quarter averageQ4 2027, 14.8 or better
New label live across all 46 SKUsSeptember 2027
Eye-level facings at two of your top four retailers6 or more by Q4 2027

The bill, one line at a time.

Retainer by scope, production in its own bucket. Each line drops on its own, and the receipt says what you lose.

We'd keep all of it for year one. If it has to come down, drop the shoot days first, then the second film. The label work and the shelf test are the two lines we'd fight for, since every other line depends on them.

How it's paid, month by month

Plain terms, open questions.

What you'd be signing

  • Three-year term, January 4, 2027 to January 3, 2030, with a 90-day out for either side at any time.
  • You own the work on final payment, including the label system, plates and every campaign asset. Unused ideas stay ours.
  • Named people. Anyone on the panel above moves off your account only with Renata's sign-off.
  • Category exclusivity in soup, broth and shelf-stable meals for the term.
  • Net 30 terms, billed monthly. Media stays with your media agency and your $31M working budget doesn't touch this bill.

What we don't know yet

  • Which territory wins. Day 38 decides, and we may lose our favorite.
  • Whether The Count can run. Beef barley has 14 ingredients today, and it's your R&D team's call whether 9 is possible.
  • Who pays for plates. 46 SKUs at about $15,000 each is $690,000 on your operations budget, outside this bill. We'd like to see that plan.
  • Ostler's reaction. They own Daybasket and may read this as a provocation. Dee knows them better than we do.
  • The share figures. They come from your review data room and we haven't seen store-level scans.

Four signatures, then we start on January 4.

Your year one number stands at $5,560,000. Tell us by December 11 and we'll be in stores with Dee's team by January 6.

Waiting on four signatures.